If the Hippocratic Oath can be taken as the highest ideal of the medical field—separate from the economic structures that have built up around it—then something like health care should be judged by its purist ideals, i.e., the Hippocratic Oath. In that sense health care is more than a mere product. Those who reduce it to a mere product in the health care debate take this oath of healing and comforting out of context. However, if those who do wish to reduce health care to a mere product that is bought and sold in an economic market, why don’t they do the same with religion? Institutional religions are, by necessity, run in similar ways to businesses and their product is that of salvation. This is not so dissimilar from the way medical care needs to be run in a business-like fashion. Yet, I have yet to hear that we should treat religious goods as products or that we treat the actual organizations of religion as businesses. Perhaps, we should separate the highest ideals of religion from its organizational necessity, the same way we do health care. If that is the case, then religious organizations could be taxed as businesses selling products—products that promise healing and salvation. This new tax on these religious organizations that deliver the product of salvation, could, perhaps, go to help fund health care or reduce taxes for the middle class. Any thoughts?
Daily Archives: July 2, 2012
MoralMindfield on Twitter
- Miracles - Can We Believe Them? wp.me/p12uUE-uV 3 weeks ago
- Boston Bomber Dzhokhar Tsarnaev Taken Alive: A Moral Victory wp.me/p12uUE-u3 1 month ago
- CMT on the Pope's embrace of a young disabled man: "A Special Vocation: To Show People How To Love" j.mp/XmaifJ 1 month ago
- Should we bring back extrinct species? The Conservation Perspective on 'De-extinction' huff.to/15KXzBq via @HuffPostGreen 1 month ago
- Brilliant animals - Frans de Waal on The Brains of the Animal Kingdom on.wsj.com/15BIuSI via @WSJ 1 month ago
Top Posts
- Cloud Atlas by David Mitchell: A Philosophical and Ethical Book Review
- Is Power Evil? The Ethics of Power
- Of Durkheim and Facebook: Social Forces and Social Media
- Martin Luther King, Ethics, and the Law
- Child Sacrifice at the Altar of the Gun God
- Surfing Our Lady of Guadalupe Has Been Removed
- Presenting and Defending Your Dissertation Proposal in Ethics and Social Theory at GTU
- After the Death of Bin Ladin: A Just War Assessment of Afghanistan
- On being in the wrong place at the wrong time
- Reflections on Individualism and Catholic Social Teaching, Part I
Blogs in the GTU Community
Links of Interest
Other Recommended Blogs
Categories
Search the MoralMindfield
-
Recent Posts
- Miracles – Can We Believe Them?
- The Three Great Tragedies
- Boston Bomber Dzhokhar Tsarnaev Taken Alive: A Moral Victory
- On the real cost of food, or, why your carrots really are worth (at least) $2.50
- China’s Blind and Barefoot Hero: Chen Guangcheng
- Reflections on the Election of Pope Francis
- “I Will Wait For You”: The Meaning and Morality of Waiting
- The Ethics of Meteor and Asteroid Defense
- Should Pope Benedict XVI Have Stepped Down?
- “Why a Four Degree Celsius Warmer World Must Be Avoided” Infographic
- Exploring secularity and the church-state divide
- Responding to the Murders at Sandy Hook Elementary School
- Child Sacrifice at the Altar of the Gun God
- Physicists to Test Simulation Hypothesis (AKA Theism)
- Trust
Calendar
Archives